Top Moments (#80 - #71) of the 2014-2015 Kansas City Royals.

This set of ten Moments commences with the most important wild pitch in franchise history, continues with a handful of iconic defensive plays, wraps up with a pair of game-icing home runs, and concludes with an event so unlikely it nearly broke the space-time continuum. And we still have 70 Moments to go.

Moment #: 80

Date: September 30, 2014

Game: 2014 Wild Card Game, vs. Oakland Athletics

Score: Oakland 7, Kansas City 5, Bottom of the 8th

Situation: One out, men on second and third

Count: 0-1

Matchup: Alex Gordon vs. Luke Gregerson

Result: Wild pitch, one run scores

WPA: 11%

Summary: In the midst of the Royals’ furious 8th-inning comeback in the Wild Card Game, Luke Gregerson throws a wild pitch to score a run and moving the tying run to third base with one out.

Link to video: Here.

When did I start to believe that the Royals not just could, but would, win the Wild Card Game? Probably around the time that Luke Gregerson bounced a slider to Alex Gordon in the dirt. Billy Butler had just singled to drive in the second run of the inning and bring the Royals to within two; Terrance Gore had pinch-run for Butler, and on the first pitch to Gordon, Gore stole second base (Moment #173) like it was nothing. Eric Hosmer was already on third base, so Gore represented the tying run, meaning that all the Royals had to do was bring home The Fastest Man In Baseball from scoring position.

And then Gregerson threw this slider too low and too inside, and Derek Norris let it bounce crazily off his glove, and Hosmer scored, and now The Fastest Man In Baseball was on third base with one out. It felt like destiny at that point. It felt like the Royals had all the momentum on their side. But as you know from the fact that I mentioned the word “momentum”, that’s not what happened at all. Gregerson walked Gordon, but rebounded to strike out Salvador Perez on three pitches (Gordon stole second base on the last of them), and then he struck out Omar Infante on four pitches. My faith was perhaps never tested more than it was at that moment, when a potentially historic four-run rally in the 8th inning of a double elimination game fell short because the Royals could not bring home Terrance Gore from third base with one out. (True story: after Perez struck out, I had such little confidence in the matchup between Infante and Gregerson that in the stands I was pushing for Gore to try to steal home. Come on: like you wouldn’t have wanted to see him try?)

Dying. Dying. All Gregerson does is throw sliders in the dirt. WHY DO WE HAVE TO SWING AT THEM

— Rany Jazayerli (@jazayerli) October 1, 2014

But thanks to this wild pitch, the Royals exited the inning down only one run instead of two. And while Gore’s stolen base was ultimately in vain, the Royals had another ace baserunner up their sleeve.

(Also, just to cut off the protests in advance: Todd Worrell’s pitch in the 9th inning of Game 6 of the 1985 World Series was scored as a passed ball, not a wild pitch.)

Moment #: 79

Date: October 11, 2014

Game: 2014 ALCS Game 2, @ Baltimore Orioles

Score: Kansas City 4, Baltimore 4, Bottom of the 6th

Situation: No outs, bases empty

Count: 0-1

Matchup: J.J. Hardy vs. Yordano Ventura

Result: Flyout to center field

WPA: 3%

Summary: Lorenzo Cain makes a spectacular catch look routine, taking extra bases away from J.J. Hardy in a tie game in the 6th inning.

Link to video: Here.

Yost left Ventura in to start the sixth because he wanted to watch Cain do that.

— Rany Jazayerli (@jazayerli) October 11, 2014

We are now entering the realm of Great Defensive Plays Made By Lorenzo Cain. You remember these, I’m sure; they were a staple of the 2014 postseason in particular. However, the sheer number of them may have caused them to all blur into one hazy, happy memory, so we need to separate them out again. This was the full-extension catch that Cain made in Baltimore in Game 2 of the ALCS, which he caught in right field even though he was, you know, playing center field. You may remember Yordano Ventura’s arms being raised up in triumph afterwards. (Ventura would come out of the game one batter later with shoulder tightness.) J.J. Hardy was leading off the bottom of the 6th inning, and was deprived of at least a double, which would have turned Caleb Joseph’s otherwise-harmless two-out single later in the inning into the go-ahead run. Thanks to Cain, the Orioles never did get that go-ahead run. Not that they didn’t keep trying, as an inning later…

Moment #: 78

Date: October 11, 2014

Game: 2014 ALCS Game 2, @ Baltimore Orioles

Score: Kansas City 4, Baltimore 4, Bottom of the 7th

Situation: Two outs, bases loaded

Count: 0-1

Matchup: J.J. Hardy vs. Kelvin Herrera

Result: Flyout to right field

WPA: 12%

Summary: Lorenzo Cain makes a tough catch look easy, taking extra bases – and at least two RBIs – away from J.J. Hardy in a tie game in the 7th inning.

Link to video: Here.

…Hardy again batted in a tie game, this time with two outs and the bases loaded, thanks to some uncharacteristic struggles by Kelvin Herrera. First Herrera somehow missed the first base bag after receiving the toss from Eric Hosmer on a routine groundball by Nick Markakis leading off the inning. Then Herrera walked Alejandra de Aza on six pitches, and the Orioles had first-and-second with no outs. Adam Jones struck out, but Nelson Cruz punched a grounder through the left side to load the bases with one out. Fortunately, Herrera got the star-crossed Steve Pearce to fly out to shallow left field, where no one would be foolish enough to test Alex Gordon’s arm, before Hardy lined an 0-1 pitch down the right field line.

But in the top of the 7th, Jarrod Dyson had pinch-run for Nori Aoki, and when the bottom of the inning started he was in center field and Cain had moved to right. So the Royals had an exceptional defender in right field, who was also shaded towards the line, in part because the presence of Dyson in center made it possible for Cain to play there. As a result, the catch itself wasn’t particularly dramatic, although Cain finished it with a dramatic 540-degree flourish. But the catch didn’t need to be dramatic only because of the defensive dominance of the Royals outfield. And the catch had an enormous impact on the game; if the ball drops, the score is 8-6 or 9-6, the Orioles probably win, and the whole series plays out differently.

Moment #: 77

Date: October 5, 2014

Game: 2014 ALDS Game 3, vs. Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim

Score: Los Angeles 2, Kansas City 7, Top of the 5th

Situation: One out, men on first and second

Count: 2-2 (+1 foul)

Matchup: Albert Pujols vs. James Shields

Result: Flyout to center field

WPA: 2%

Summary: Lorenzo Cain makes a spectacular diving catch to rob Albert Pujols of a hit with two men aboard…

Link to video: Here.

Moment #: 76

Date: October 5, 2014

Game: 2014 ALDS Game 3, vs. Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim

Score: Los Angeles 2, Kansas City 7, Top of the 5th

Situation: Two outs, men on first and second

Count: 0-1

Matchup: Howie Kendrick vs. James Shields

Result: Flyout to center field

WPA: 2%

Summary: …and then Cain makes a spectacular sliding catch to rob Howie Kendrick as well.

Link to video: Here.

"For maximum strength pain relief, try Lorenzocaine!"

— Rany Jazayerli (@jazayerli) October 6, 2014

These plays are inseparable, coming as they did on back-to-back batters, so it would be inappropriate to discuss them separately. Unlike Cain’s catches in Baltimore, these two catches didn’t come at a critical time, coming as they did in a game the Royals led by five runs in a series they led 2 games to 0. But what they lacked in impact they made up for in visual aesthetics, and in the way they seemed to announce to the world that the Royals were for real: that they played defense better than any other playoff team did anything.

First Cain went to his right to rob Pujols, diving headfirst to make the play. Then he went to his left slightly, but mostly straight in, one of the most difficult reads for a centerfielder to make, and robbed Kendrick by sliding feet-first. Cain then got up and flexed his arms so impressively that he also won the Mr. Olympia competition.

Even James Shields was in disbelief by the end. It was the complete array of Cain’s skill set demonstrated in the span of two batters, and to whatever extent the Angels still thought they were alive in the ALDS, I’d like to think these two back-to-back catches also robbed them of whatever was left of their morale. More to the point, these two catches made the rest of baseball sit up and take notice: that not only were the Royals a very dangerous playoff team, they were an absolute joy to watch.

Moment #: 75

Date: October 15, 2014

Game: 2014 ALCS Game 4, vs. Baltimore Orioles

Score: Baltimore 1, Kansas City 2, Top of the 5th

Situation: No outs, bases empty

Count: 1-2

Matchup: J.J. Hardy vs. Jason Vargas

Result: Flyout to left field

WPA: 3%

Summary: Alex Gordon crashes into the wall but holds on to the ball, making a sensational catch to preserve a one-run lead in the 2014 ALCS finale.

Link to video: Here.

Jason Vargas is trying to kill his defenders. AND THEY WON'T LET HIM

— Rany Jazayerli (@jazayerli) October 15, 2014

It’s no wonder J.J. Hardy had such a bad season in 2015. You would have too if you couldn’t get a good night’s sleep the entire winter before.

With the Orioles in desperate straits, down 3 games to 0 and losing by a run in the 5th inning of Game 4, Hardy scalded a 1-2 fastball from Jason Vargas over Alex Gordon’s head in left field. But not over Gordon’s glove. Gordon made the over-the-shoulder catch at full speed less than two steps from the fence, and not the padded portion of the fence – the chain-link cover over one of the display boards out there. A collision with that wall was going to hurt, and it did, knocking the wind out of Gordon. But he held on to the ball. The Royals held on to the lead. And despite being unable to score any insurance runs against Baltimore, the Royals held that lead all the way to the end.

"How can we take WAR seriously when it ranks Alex Gordon as one of the best players in baseball?" - no one ever again, I hope.

— Rany Jazayerli (@jazayerli) October 15, 2014

The Royals probably never played defense as well as they did in the 2014 ALCS, and this was their last great play of the series. In doing so, Gordon not only displayed the Royals’ amazing defensive skills, but also their willingness to go to the ends of the earth to make a play. (No play demonstrated that better than Gordon’s dive into the stands in Chicago last April, a play which I flat-out forgot about when putting together this list. My bad. Is it too late to extend the list to 219?)

Moment #: 74

Date: September 30, 2014

Game: 2014 Wild Card Game, vs. Oakland Athletics

Score: Oakland 8, Kansas City 8, Bottom of the 12th

Situation: Two outs, man on first

Count: 1-2

Matchup: Salvador Perez vs. Jason Hammel

Result: Stolen Base (Christian Colon)

WPA: 4%

Summary: With the score tied in the bottom of the 12th in the Wild Card Game, Christian Colon steals second base on a pitchout – and is safe when the pitch bounces out of the catcher’s glove.

Link to video: Here.

We don’t talk enough about this play when we talk about the Wild Card Game, or about what a charmed existence this franchise has lived these past two years. The Oakland A’s knew Christian Colon was going. They pitched out. Do you know how rarely teams pitch out these days? I didn’t, until Ben Lindbergh wrote about it for FiveThirtyEight recently, and pointed out that the frequency of pitchouts has dropped by over 75% in the last 25 years. During the regular season, Bob Melvin called for 16 pitchouts – total. Over the last three seasons combined, he’s called for 44 – less than 15 per season. The A’s pitch out less than one time every ten games. And yet, with the Wild Card Game tied in the bottom of the 12th inning, the A’s pitched out, and guessed correctly. What’s more, they pitched out against Christian Colon, who isn’t exactly Terrance Gore on the bases. Colon is 5-for-7 (71.4%) in stolen bases in his brief major league career and 71-for-99 (71.7%) in his minor league career; his career high for steals in a season is 18. He’s a decent stolen base threat, but he’s exactly the sort of guy where guessing right on a pitchout should be the difference between probably being safe and probably being out.

And he was safe anyway, because Derek Norris dropped the ball. On the replay, you can see that as the pitch reaches his glove he’s looking out towards second base, presumably at Colon, rather than at the baseball. This is what I meant when I said that when it came to stealing bases, the Royals were totally in the A’s heads by the end of the game. Norris was focused on the wrong thing, and literally dropped the opportunity to end the inning by throwing Colon out at second base. Two pitches later, Salvador Perez ended the game instead.

Moment #: 73

Date: October 10, 2014

Game: 2014 ALCS Game 1, @ Baltimore Orioles

Score: Kansas City 6, Baltimore 5, Top of the 10th

Situation: One out, man on first

Count: 3-2

Matchup: Mike Moustakas vs. Darren O’Day

Result: Home Run, two runs score

WPA: 12%

Summary: Mike Moustakas ices the opener of the 2014 ALCS when he hits the Royals’ second homer of the 10th inning.

Link to video: Here.

Game 1 of the 2014 ALCS is perhaps the most underrated of all 22 of the Royals’ postseason victories, a game in which the Royals blew a 4-1 lead in the 5th, failed to score in the top of the 9th in a tie game after loading the bases with none out…and managed to win anyway. Alex Gordon had already put the Royals ahead when he led off the 10th with a home run off of Darren O’Day, but after Salvador Perez walked and Omar Infante struck out, Buck Showalter called on left-hander Brian Matusz to face Mike Moustakas. Moustakas worked the count full and then Matusz threw a 90 mph meatball up and right over the plate. Moustakas may have still only been a mistake hitter before his rebirth as an all-fields hitter the following season, but he knew what to do with a mistake. The two-run homer gave Kansas City an 8-5 lead, and those two insurance runs proved crucial when Greg Holland gave up a single, a walk, and an RBI single with two outs in the bottom of the inning before closing the game out.

Bonus highlight: after the home run, it’s the first appearance of Sad Orioles Chick!

I know I’m a terrible person for saying this, but after a generation of being bullied, there has been a sense of giddy disbelief these past two Octobers seeing the images of so many people on the other side – players or fans – who are having their dreams crushed by the Royals. Sad Orioles Chick, who the internet tells me is actually named Morgan Sebach, became a staple of the ALCS, in part because she was at every game – and kudos to her for traveling to Kansas City for Games 3 and 4, I have nothing but respect for her commitment to her team – and in part because the cameras would turn to her for her reaction every time the Royals smacked the Orioles down. Which was pretty much all the time.

Moment #: 72

Date: October 12, 2015

Game: 2015 ALDS Game 4, @ Houston Astros

Score: Kansas City 7, Houston 6, Top of the 9th

Situation: One out, man on first

Count: 2-0

Matchup: Eric Hosmer vs. Josh Fields

Result: Home Run, two runs score

WPA: 12%

Summary: Eric Hosmer completes the Columbus Day Miracle, hitting a two-run homer to ice Game 4 of the ALDS an inning after the Royals stared elimination in the face.

Link to video: Here.

The Royals had just resuscitated their season one inning earlier, but even with a one-run lead in the 9th inning, the Royals were still not guaranteed to return the 2015 ALDS back to Kansas City for Game 5. Wade Davis had already pitched the 8th, and there was no guarantee he would pitch another scoreless inning. (Yes, I realize that Davis giving up the tying run would require an Act of God, but if Acts of God didn’t happen, they wouldn’t list them in tiny print under the qualifiers in any standard insurance contract, now would they?)

But in the top of the 9th, Eric Hosmer decided to remove even that exceedingly unlikely situation from happening. With Lorenzo Cain Ben Zobrist on first and one out, Hosmer hit Josh Fields’ 2-0 fastball a very loooong way. Minute Maid Park is a good home run park, but that is because the fences are short down the lines; out towards center field it is much deeper, including the area around Tal’s Hill which gives it the deepest centerfield in the major leagues. Hosmer hit this ball to a very deep part of the ballpark, but still managed to drop it in the bullpen, a drive listed at a prodigious 452 feet. (The exit velocity off the bat was 105 mph, which was actually slower than Hosmer’s line drive off of Javier Lopez in Moment #84. That’s how hard Hosmer hit that single.) This was the only home run he hit during the 2015 playoffs, and while it didn’t come at the most crucial moment, it was still a pretty big hit. Most of his hits are.

Moment #: 71

Date: October 5, 2014

Game: 2014 ALDS Game 3, vs. Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim

Score: Los Angeles 1, Kansas City 5, Bottom of the 3rd

Situation: One out, man on first

Count: 0-1

Matchup: Alex Gordon vs. Hector Santiago

Result: Stolen Base

WPA: 1%

Summary: Billy Butler stole a base. In a major league game. A playoff game. I swear. There were witnesses and everything.

Link to video: Here.

I DIED. I JUST DIED. I MUST BE IN HEAVEN. BILLY BUTLER STOLE A BASE.

— Rany Jazayerli (@jazayerli) October 6, 2014

Billy Butler stole second base. Seriously, what else do you need to know?

The Royals had just broken open Game 3 of the ALDS against the Angels on Eric Hosmer’s two-run blast (Moment #87), so this stolen base wasn’t really necessary. And Butler didn’t score after Alex Gordon grounded out and Salvador Perez struck out to end the inning, so this stolen base wasn’t really productive. But in response, all I have to say is Billy Butler stole a base. In a playoff game.

Butler did not steal a base during the 2014 regular season. He did not attempt to steal a base during the regular season.

Butler did not steal a base in 2013. He did not attempt to steal a base in 2013.

Butler did not steal a base in 2015. He did not attempt to steal a base in 2015.

In the last three seasons, Billy Butler has attempted to steal a base only one time. This is that one time. And he was safe. Against a left-handed pitcher. Hector Santiago isn’t a particularly easy pitcher to run on – during the season, runners were just 10-for-17 (59%) in stolen base attempts. But Butler went. And he was safe.

There have been many, many, many great moments in the last two years. But I would describe very few moments as surreal. This was surreal, as if Terrance Gore had just come off the bench to knock a pinch-hit homer. This was a moment that made you wonder if all this was scripted somewhere, that made you look for the director behind the curtain to come out and yell “Cut!”

This moment didn’t make sense. Not one person in the stadium that day thought it made sense. Look at Butler flashing Jarrod Dyson’s “vroom vroom” sign.

Then look at the cutaway to the fans in the stands. Then see them cut away to Dyson and Yordano Ventura flashing the sign back at Butler.

The picture of those two remains one of the most joyful images of the past two years. It radiates pure joy, adulterated perhaps only by sheer disbelief.

Billy Butler stole second base. It didn’t matter at all in the end. But to this day it serves as the perfect emblem of the last two seasons. The moment didn’t make any sense. I still can’t believe it really happened. Just like I still can’t believe the 2014-2015 Royals really happened.