I may not
have the time to write about the Royals nearly as often as I used to, but when
the Kansas City Star asks me to write for the Sunday paper 1200 words of hot
fire (TM, Sam Mellinger) on the developing nightmare that is the
2014 season, I’m there. If you haven’t read it already, you can do so here. I
hope you like it.
Because
newspapers are not printed on scrolls, I didn’t have the time to expound on
every little detail about the Royals; fortunately, that’s why I have this blog.
Let’s talk about some those other issues.
- To be completely fair, it’s a little early to characterize this season as a disaster quite yet, which
is why I stepped just short of the line of calling for Dayton Moore to be fired
this instant. The 2014 AL is just crazily compressed, more than I can ever
recall a league being at the beginning of June.
Yes, the Royals are in last
place in the AL Central as I write this, but they’re also just two games out of
second place. They’re in 13th place in the American League (!), but just 3.5
games out of the wild-card spot. Call it the 15-out-of-20 rule, in honor of
Moore’s drop-the-mic moment from last year: so long as the Royals can
reasonably expect to lead the wild-card race if they win 15 of their next 20
games, it’s premature to give up on the season – and the front office –
entirely.
But I am
becoming more and more skeptical that such a thing is possible by the moment.
It’s not just that the longer the season goes on, the more likely it is that Eric
Hosmer and Billy Butler and the newly-returned Mike Moustakas are not just in an epic early-season slump,
but that this is simply who they are. It’s not just that the longer the season
goes on, the more likely it seems that the Royals may in fact finish with fewer
home runs than Barry Bonds hit by himself in 2001.
For one,
there’s the schedule. As I wrote back in early April, the Royals actually had
one of the easier early-season schedules in baseball, easy enough that it was
entirely reasonable that they would be 34-22 at this point. Instead, they’re
26-30, and now it gets harder – with the necessary caveat that it’s not
entirely clear which teams are good and which teams are bad this year. They’ve
finished their entire season series with the Astros, for instance – and didn’t
that go well! – but have yet to play the Yankees or Red Sox at all. If
you believe the current standings, that doesn’t sound so bad. If you believe
that there’s some relevance to the Red Sox being defending world champions, it doesn’t.
They just
played a Blue Jays team which looks like it will be a force in the AL East all
season, and were lucky to get a split – if Jose Reyes simply completes a
routine throw from shortstop to end Thursday night’s game, the Royals would
have lost three of four. From now until June 30th, the Royals play the
Cardinals, Yankees, Indians, White Sox, Tigers, Mariners, Dodgers, and Angels.
There are no patsies in that bunch. They could easily repeat their 12-17 May
with a 12-16 June, in which case they’ll be 38-45 and the pressure will be on
the front office to sell as the trading deadline approaches. Specifically, the
pressure will be on them to trade James Shields. For a lot less than they
acquired him for. It’s a lot to ask your general manager to make a move that
almost by definition will acknowledge that the signature transaction of his
tenure was a mistake.
Beyond that,
there’s the stark reality that there ain’t no cavalry coming from the minors
this season. While the farm system is pretty good overall, let’s not mince
words: most of the Royals’ prospects have been disappointing this season, and
the best of them are still in A-ball. The one who hasn’t, Yordano Ventura, gave
us all a frightful scare last week, and while reports couldn’t be better – he might
well be back on the mound this week – the reality is that the Royals are 26-30 with Ventura, and his availability the
rest of the season is not entirely certain.
Kyle Zimmer,
who was supposed to lead the cavalry, may not be on a mound until August after
a strained lat muscle further delayed his recovery from “minor” arm soreness –
and once again raised the question of whether the Royals are being entirely
straight with us. Who else can the Royals call on? We’ve already seen their
options in the lineup – Johnny Giavotella, Jimmy Paredes, Pedro Ciriaco – which
are collectively so appealing that when Danny Valencia had to go on the DL
today, the Royals brought Mike Moustakas back after eight whole games in Omaha
and declared him fixed. (And it speaks volumes that through all this, Christian
Colon – who’s hitting .280/.333/.372 – is the one guy we haven’t seen in Kansas City.)
And on the
pitching side…um, did you see Aaron Brooks’ start on Saturday? Actually, maybe
it’s better if you didn’t. If you’re thinking of jumping someone from Double-A,
the Northwest Arkansas Naturals are 18-36, so don’t. (Actually that’s not fair –
Angel Baez could be the Royals’ next fire-breathing reliever, and it’s entirely
possible that Orlando Calixte could be the Royals’ best option at third base by
September. But no one's going to help right now.)
Realistically,
the only way this roster is going to be upgraded is from outside the
organization…which means doubling down on trading future prospects for present
talent. That’s a fine thing to do if the Royals are in the thick of a wild-card
race. Right now, it’s Russian Roulette with only one chamber that doesn’t have a bullet.
Making this
season particularly frustrating is that, once again, the Royals can’t blame
injuries – they’ve been pretty healthy ever since Luke Hochevar went down with
Tommy John surgery. Lorenzo Cain has been on the DL, but that’s what you get
with Cain, and the Royals are well covered there with Jarrod Dyson. Omar Infante
has been on the DL, but that’s what you get with Infante, and the Royals got
him back as fast as they could. And now Valencia is on the DL, but if the
Royals’ chances come down to a healthy Danny Valencia, they might as well pack
it in right now. And on the pitching side, Tim Collins and Francisley Bueno
were on the DL, and Bruce Chen is on there now, but that’s it – the Royals’ #5
starter and two situational relievers.
Maybe the
Royals’ individual players will show improvement, but that improvement is
likely to be counteracted by injuries to core players. Losing Ventura for just
one start showed how little pitching depth the Royals have right now. The
Royals didn’t make much of it, but Danny Duffy’s velocity was way down his last
time out, and forgive me if I don’t accept Ned Yost’s excuse of a “dead arm”
until I see that velocity come back. And if Gordon or Alcides Escobar or
Salvador Perez goes down for an extended period of time…God help us.
So I’m not
convinced that the Royals can play that
much better than they already have – and I’m fairly convinced that given their schedule,
they’ll have to play better just to maintain their disappointing record so far.
They’ll have to play a lot better to
get back into the wild-card race, because eventually one of the other nine
teams ahead of them will get really hot. The Tigers and A’s will almost
certainly win 90 games; I think the Blue Jays have a good chance to get there
too, particularly if they make a move to pick up a pitcher (you may have heard
that James Shields would look awfully good there). The Angels strike me as a
team that could get hot awfully fast, especially now that Josh Hamilton is
ready to re-join their lineup. That just means one team – the Red Sox, Yankees,
Rangers all seem like good candidates – needs to go on a tear, and the Royals
will be left in their wake.
Even if it
takes just 88 wins to make the playoffs in the AL this year (it took 92 last
year,) that would require the Royals to go 62-44 the rest of the season. I’m
not saying it can’t happen – they did go 43-27 after the All-Star Break last
year. I’m saying that betting on another second-half rebound is betting on
hope. And as the Royals have demonstrated year after year after year, hope is
not a strategy.
David Glass
doesn’t have to make any decisions now. He shouldn’t, quite frankly; the draft
starts in a couple of days, and you might recall that Moore was hired just
before the draft the last time around, and the lack of clear leadership in the
war room led to Luke Hochevar #1 overall, and (nearly as damning) not a single
major leaguer of note drafted between Hochevar and their final pick, Jarrod
Dyson. For that reason alone the front office should be left alone for the next
week or two.
But I don’t
think I’m being unreasonable when I say that if 2014 was the make-or-break year
for Moore, then June is his make-or-break month. If the Royals can climb back
to .500 by month’s end, then maybe the grim reaper should be held back for a
little while longer. If they get over .500 and are a serious threat in the
wild-card race, maybe it will even be best to let the season play out, even if
it means holding onto Shields and taking the draft pick the way the Royals did
with Ervin Santana last year.
But if the
Royals aren’t any higher in the standings at the end of June than they are at
the beginning of it, it’s time for the owner to do what only the owner can do.
I was 30 when Moore was hired; I turn 39 in two weeks. I’ve come to the
realization that I may have wasted my 30s rooting for a payoff that never came.
I have no intention of wasting my 40s the same way.