This set of five Moments include a pair of run-scoring doubles with no outs and the Royals down 2-0 in the last game of the World Series, and while the first one proved to be insufficient, the second one made all the difference; the tying and go-ahead hits against David Price in the most pivotal inning of the 2015 ALCS; and one of only two walkoff wins in the last two postseasons. And we still have 30 Moments to go.
Moment #: 35
Date: November 1, 2015
Game: 2015 World Series, Game 5, @ New York Mets
Score: Kansas City 0, New York 2, Top of the 9th
Situation: No outs, man on second
Matchup: Eric Hosmer vs. Matt Harvey
Result: Double, one run scores
Summary: After Matt Harvey lobbies his manager to stay in to pitch the 9th inning, Eric Hosmer makes him pay.
THIS IS FUN— Rany Jazayerli (@jazayerli) November 2, 2015
I’m very curious to see the reception that Matt Harvey gets at Kauffman Stadium on Opening Night. The natural inclination is to boo, I know, but shouldn’t we be cheering the guy who, through sheer force of stubbornness, coerced his manager into opening the door for the Royals to mount a game-tying rally in the 9th inning?
Harvey had already walked Lorenzo Cain on seven pitches to start the 9th, and still Terry Collins stuck with him. On the first pitch to Eric Hosmer, Cain stole second base. And on the second pitch, Harvey’s 111th and final pitch in the final game of the 111th World Series, he threw a 94 mph fastball that tailed away, and Hosmer did a masterful job of slicing the ball deep to left field, over Michael Conforto’s head and off the wall for an RBI double. And then, finally, Collins called upon Jeurys Familia.
What’s striking about the video is the fear you can hear in the crowd after the double. Sure, the Royals had just scored a run, and the tying run was on second base with no outs – but the Mets still had the lead, and home field advantage. But you can sense the crowd’s reaction already starting to turn: here we go again.
And the best part? The crowd was right. Damn it was fun rooting for these guys.
Moment #: 34
Date: October 17, 2015
Game: 2015 ALCS Game 2, vs. Toronto Blue Jays
Score: Toronto 3, Kansas City 2, Bottom of the 7th
Situation: One out, man on second
Matchup: Mike Moustakas vs. David Price
Result: Single, tying run scores
Summary: Mike Moustakas ties Game 2 of the 2015 ALCS in the 7th inning with a single off of the player who was selected ahead of him in the 2007 draft.
This team is harder to kill than that Brotherhood Without Banners dude in Westeros.— Rany Jazayerli (@jazayerli) October 17, 2015
I thought I had covered all the possible storylines and narratives that the 2014-2015 Royals have run roughshod over, but it turns out I missed one: the narrative of How Could The Royals Let David Price Slip Through Their Hands.
You might not remember this narrative, but I do, because I practically invented it. To briefly review: in 2006, Dayton Moore’s first year as general manager, the Royals were the worst team in baseball. With three games left in the season, they had already lost 100 games. The Tampa Bay Devil Rays were 61-98, but unless the Rays got swept in their final series of the season against Cleveland and the Royals swept their final opponent, the Detroit Tigers, the Royals would finish the season with the worst record in the major leagues.
And that’s exactly what happened. The shock isn’t that the Devil Rays got swept; the shock is that the Royals swept the Tigers. Shocking, because this was the season the Tigers completed the greatest three-year turnaround in baseball history – after setting an American League record with 119 losses in 2003, the Tigers were the toast of baseball in 2006, starting the season 76-36. They then sort of collapsed down the stretch, and came into the final series of the year tied for first place in the AL Central after leading the division by ten games in early August. But still: they were 95-64. The Royals were 59-100.
Shocking, because going into the final series, the Tigers had beaten the Royals 14 times in 15 games.
Shocking, because the series was in Detroit. And it’s not like the Tigers had nothing to play for – the division was up for grabs.
Somehow, and in characteristic “the Royals can’t even win for losing” fashion, the Royals swept the Tigers. On Friday, they trailed 5-2 after six innings, then scored single runs in the 7th, 8th, and 9th and tied the game when John Buck (!) and pinch-hitter Shane Costa (!!) singled with two outs in the 9th. The Royals then hit three homers in the 11th (!!!) and withstood a two-run comeback from the Tigers in the bottom of the inning.
On Saturday, the Royals scored seven runs in the top of the 1st (!!!!), and won, 9-6.
On Sunday, the Royals trailed 7-4 going to the 8th inning, but scored four runs on a rally the 2014-2015 Royals could admire: a hit batter, a walk, two singles, an error by third baseman Brandon Inge, a walk, and a single. In the bottom of the 8th, Matt Stairs – who the Royals had traded away earlier in the year – tried to do his old team a favor by homering to tie the game. In the bottom of the 11th, the Tigers loaded the bases with one out, but Inge struck out swinging and then Jimmy Gobble (I’m running out of exclamation marks!!!!!) came in to retire Curtis Granderson. The Royals scored two in the 12th and held on for the win. It was one of the most dramatic, random, and completely counterproductive sweeps in the history of baseball.
Why do I say that? Why am I telling you about a series that happened to a last-place Royals team a decade ago? Because by sweeping the Tigers that weekend, the Royals finished with a better record than the Tampa Bay Devil Rays, which meant that instead of getting the #1 pick in the 2007 draft, they had to settle for the #2 pick. If they had lost any of those three games, they would have drafted first overall. And it was clear – even in September, nine months before the draft – who that first pick would be: David Price.
Price was the kind of elite, nearly major league ready collegiate starting pitcher that comes along once a decade if that, not quite in Stephen Strasburg’s class – no one before or since has been in Strasburg’s class – but up there with any other college pitcher taken with the #1 pick: Andy Benes, Ben McDonald, Floyd Bannister, Paul Wilson. He was pretty much a guaranteed All-Star. (McDonald and Wilson looked like top-of-the-rotation guys before their arms went lame, in large part because they pitched in an era when 130-pitch outings were typical.)
Meanwhile, no one knew who the second pick would be – not in September, and not even in June, when the Royals were planning until 24 hours before the draft to take Josh Vitters (who went #3 to the Cubs instead) before settling on…Mike Moustakas. And then Moustakas nearly went to college instead, signing just minutes before the deadline – close enough that Joe Posnanski had another column ready to run in the Kansas City Star the next morning if Moustakas hadn’t signed. (And reportedly Moustakas signed against the recommendation of his advisor, one Scott Boras.)
The story had a happy ending for Tampa Bay. Price made his pro debut in 2008, the year they changed their name to the Rays, and the year they changed their fortunes from hapless losers to the best dollar-for-dollar team in the game. Price ripped through three minor league levels and was promoted in September, not making his major league debut until September 14th, but he was Brandon Finnegan before Brandon Finnegan was – moved to the bullpen for the playoffs, Price saved the Rays’ hides in the ALCS against Boston.
This is largely forgotten now, but the Rays were up 3 games to 1 in the series and had a 7-0 lead in the middle of the 7th inning in Game 5 – and the Red Sox scored four in the 7th, three in the 8th to tie, and walked it off in the bottom of the 9th, a miracle that would impress even the 2014-2015 Royals. The Red Sox then won Game 6. In Game 7, the Rays led 3-1 after seven innings, but an error, a single, and a walk loaded the bases with two outs before Joe Maddon turned in desperation to Price – his fifth pitcher of the inning – to face J.D. Drew. Price struck Drew out, and pitched a scoreless 9th inning to send Tampa Bay to the World Series. Even then, I wrote about what a break the Rays had gotten when the Royals swept the Tigers two years before.
That would have been enough, but then David Price turned into one of the best pitchers in baseball. He made four All-Star Games as a member of the Rays, won a Cy Young Award, and was a Cy Young runner-up.
The story had a happy ending for Detroit as well. Despite somehow losing out on the division and the #1 seed in the playoffs, the Tigers still qualified for the postseason as the wild card team, back before there was a play-in game. Detroit then won seven straight games to win the AL pennant – Minnesota lost in the first round – before being upset in five games in the World Series. And then, eight years later, they acquired Price from Tampa Bay. Price was his typically excellent self as a member of the Tigers, and in his one playoff start in 2014 allowed two runs in eight innings, although he got saddled with the loss anyway. And when they fell out of the race in 2015, the Tigers cashed Price in and got three prospects, including Daniel Norris, in return.
But, incredibly, the story had a happy ending for the Royals as well. Mike Moustakas turned into a top prospect, and then he turned into a promising major league, if not a star like Price was. And then he was pretty terrible for two seasons, and in 2013 you could argue that had the Royals drafted Price (who in an off-year still had 2.8 bWAR) instead of Moustakas (who had -0.1 bWAR), they might have bridged the five-game gap between them and the playoffs. But in 2014, the Royals made it to the playoffs despite a terrible year from Moustakas. They almost certainly would have won the division with Price instead of Moustakas – particularly since the Tigers wouldn’t have been able to acquire him – but then they wouldn’t have won the Wild Card Game, which set them on an emotional trajectory all the way to the World Series, and they wouldn’t have benefitted from Moustakas’ five home runs in the playoffs.
And in 2015, Moustakas became the player the Royals thought he could be. He still wasn’t quite as good as Price during the regular season (Price had 6.0 bWAR to Moustakas’ 4.4), but he was plenty good enough for the Royals to finish with the best record in the AL. And in Game 2 of the ALCS, after David Price had utterly dominated the Royals for six innings, they had scored two runs and had the tying run on second base with one out when Moustakas stepped into the batter’s box. And on a 2-2 pitch, finally vindicating what happened nearly a decade earlier, Moustakas lined Price’s changeup over Ryan Goins’ head for a base hit.
Eric Hosmer didn’t hesitate and took off for third base on contact, but he was barely at third base when Jose Bautista fielded the ball. Of all the decisions Mike Jirschele has made at third base the last two postseasons, this is the only one I really question – he sent Hosmer with one out, when a halfway decent throw gets him at the plate. In fact, as off-line as Bautista’s throw was, had his throw been six inches closer, or had Russell Martin shuffled his feet over a bit more and grabbed the ball on the bounce, Martin would have had a good chance to get Hosmer with the swipe tag before Hosmer crossed the plate. I understand that the Royals wanted to push the envelope against Bautista’s defense, but with only one out I don’t think the risk was worth it. But it worked out perfectly. Not only did Hosmer score, but Moustakas took second base on the throw home, setting up the next Moment on our list.
I guess the only team that the David Price Story didn’t have a happy ending for was the Blue Jays; they lost all three playoff games that Price started for them. We’ll save Moustakas’ at-bat against him in Game 6 for a little later.
Oh, and if the Royals had drafted Price? He would have walked away as a free agent this winter. Moustakas, on the other hand, is a Royal for at least two more years.
I didn’t see a way for the Royals to win the exchange back in 2007. I certainly didn’t see a way for them to win the exchange in 2013. But then the Royals have spent the last two years proving that they’ll find a way to win even when one doesn’t exist.
Moment #: 33
Date: October 17, 2015
Game: 2015 ALCS Game 2, vs. Toronto Blue Jays
Score: Toronto 3, Kansas City 3, Bottom of the 7th
Situation: Two outs, man on second
Count: 3-2 (+2 fouls)
Matchup: Alex Gordon vs. David Price
Result: Double, go-ahead run scores
Summary: Alex Gordon follows with a two-out double to drive in the go-ahead run and chase David Price from the game.
This team. This team. THIS TEAM.— Rany Jazayerli (@jazayerli) October 17, 2015
After Mike Moustakas tied Game 2 with his single, Salvador Perez struck out looking on a very questionable full-count pitch, bringing Alex Gordon to the plate with two outs. As with Moustakas, the count ran to 2-and-2, and then Gordon fouled off a pitch, and then he took a changeup down, fouled off another pitch, and finally lined a 95 mph fastball into the right-center field gap, easily scoring Moustakas with the go-ahead run, and chasing David Price – who had entered the inning having retired 18 of 19 batters and having thrown just 66 pitches – from the game.
Three lefties had faced Price in the inning: Eric Hosmer had singled on a changeup, Moustakas had singled on a changeup, and Gordon had taken a two-strike changeup before hitting a fastball for a double. After the series ended, Tom Verducci revealed that Price had been subtly telegraphing his changeup – taking an extra breath between pitches before throwing one – that the Royals’ advance scouting had picked up on.
This is perhaps the best testament you can make to Dayton Moore: that he not only built a championship roster, but that he’s built a championship organization. When it comes to advance scouting, or coaching (think Rusty Kuntz), or even windmilling (think Mike Jirschele), the Royals take a back seat to no one. A lot of times that stuff doesn’t matter. And sometimes that stuff directly leads to the most pivotal inning of the ALCS.
Moment #: 32
Date: October 29, 2014
Game: 2014 World Series Game 7
Score: San Francisco 2, Kansas City 0, Bottom of the 2nd
Situation: No outs, man on first
Matchup: Alex Gordon vs. Tim Hudson
Result: Double, one run scores
Summary: With the Royals down 2-0 in Game 7 of the World Series, Alex Gordon brings the Royals back with an RBI double in the 2nd before scoring the tying run.
Like another Alex Gordon base hit later in this game, we shouldn’t let the final outcome overshadow just how huge this play was. It was Game 7 of the World Series, after all, and the Giants had just scored two runs in the top of the 2nd when Jeremy Guthrie grazed Pablo Sandoval with a pitch, Hunter Pence and Brandon Belt followed with singles, and Michael Morse and Brandon Crawford both hit sacrifice flies. (Of all the reasons to be upset about the outcome of Game 7, the fact that it was essentially decided by a hit-by-pitch might be the one that irks me the most.)
Even with 24 outs to go, the temptation was there to panic, because we knew Madison He-Who-Shall-Not-Be-Named was lurking, and if we knew how much and how effective he would pitch we would have panicked even more. But Billy Butler led off the bottom of the 2nd with a single up the middle, and on Tim Hudson’s first pitch, Gordon split the gap in right-center field and the ball rolled all the way to the wall. Even with no outs, Mike Jirschele sent Butler from first on an aggressive send; Jirschele must have gauged the speed of the runner and the vector of the ball perfectly, because Butler was safe by a clear but uncomfortable margin. The Giants’ lead was cut to 2-1, and the tying run was in scoring position with none out. And sure enough, the Royals matched the Giants’ talent for runner advancement, as Gordon would move up to third base on a flyout to left field by Mike Moustakas and score on a lineout to center field by Omar Infante. The score was tied at 2-2, and the Royals had once again stepped back from the precipice of defeat. Unfortunately, the Giants would push them back one more time.
Every play in a World Series Game 7 is magnified, and with a WPA of +13%, this was the biggest play of the game for the Royals – even Gordon’s single/error with two outs in the 9th only raised their Win Probability by 11%. And as I detailed in this article, in a Game 7, your WPA is the same as your CPA – Championship Probability Added. This Moment raised the Royals’ odds of winning a world championship by 13%. By that measure, it was the Royals’ biggest play of 2014.
Moment #: 31
Date: October 27, 2015
Game: 2015 World Series Game 1, vs. New York Mets
Score: New York 4, Kansas City 4, Bottom of the 14th
Situation: No outs, bases loaded
Matchup: Eric Hosmer vs. Bartolo Colon
Result: Walkoff Sacrifice Fly
Summary: Eric Hosmer hits a fly ball deep enough to drive in Alcides Escobar with the winning run for just the fourth walkoff win in Royals postseason history.
HELL TO THE EFFING YEAH— Rany Jazayerli (@jazayerli) October 28, 2015
In 31 postseason games – 22 of them victories – the Royals had only two victories of the walkoff variety. That’s not unusual over the course of a season – if one out of every 11 victories is a walkoff win, that’s seven or eight walkoff wins in a season for an average team – but it’s lower than you’d expect for these Royals given how many of their playoff games were incredibly close or decided late. Put it this way: they scored the winning run in the 9th inning or later five times in nine road playoff victories, but just twice in 13 home playoff wins. As hard as it is to believe, the Moments at the top of this list would have been even more dramatic had, say all of their extra-inning home runs occurred at home.
One of their two walkoff wins at home needs no introduction, and will rank as high on this list as you’d think it would. The other one, though – this one – ranks about as low as it’s possible for a walkoff win in the postseason – let alone the World Series – can rank, because when Eric Hosmer batted in the bottom of the 14th inning – after Alcides Escobar had reached base on David Wright’s error (Moment #58), after Ben Zobrist singled him to third base (Moment #45), and after the Mets chose to intentionally walk Lorenzo Cain – the bases were loaded with nobody out. The odds that the Royals would score in the inning were about 88%; the odds that they’d win the game were 94% (factoring in their 50% chance of winning had the game continued to the 15th). So while it wasn’t a foregone conclusion that the game would end right here, it was a pretty good bet – particularly with Bartolo Colon on the mound, not exactly the kind of pitcher who can strike his way out of a bases loaded, no out situation.
But Eric Hosmer did his job, and in doing his job he atoned for his 8th-inning error that allowed Juan Lagares to score the go-ahead run with two outs – one of the worst moments for the Royals in the last two years. Colon got two strikes on Hosmer, but – Team Contact! – he could not get the third. Hosmer got a 90 mph fastball over the plate and hit it in the air, exactly what he wanted to do, to medium-depth right field. Frankly, Curtis Granderson – who is not known for having a strong arm at all – made a tremendous play to make this play as close as it was, backing up and getting a running start on his throw so that he could hit the catcher on the fly. But Escobar was just too fast, and the throw wasn’t drop-dead perfect, and – unlike in 2014 – the Royals had won Game 1 of the World Series.
(The other two walkoff wins in Royals postseason history: Game 3 of the 1980 World Series, and Game 6 – of course – of the 1985 World Series.)